| Joined: | Wed Apr 18th, 2012 |
| Location: | United Kingdom |
| Posts: | 4193 |
| Status: |
Offline
|
I think for competitions etc that the content credentials should have to be switched on so any AI will be shown so no cheating goes on.
Surely that's down to the organisers specifying the rules of the competition? You can enable Content Credentials AFTER doing the editing and it doesn't retrospectively show what you had done.
I do think we are getting our knickers in a twist to some extent over this subject.
The key point is....has AI (ie Adobe Firefly) been used to replace key parts of the image? This might contravene the competition rules.
I didn't think AI/Firefly use could be switched off in content credentials? Isn't it only the editing actions that are switchable?
To my mind, it doesn't matter if you use the clone tool to remove detail or use the content aware feature to do it... it's still basic editing using software features.
If you choose to add or replace large elements like a sky or scenery and you do it manually with your own image stock, then its down to the competition organisers to specify that the photograph should be unaltered ....'as shot'.
But then, what about adjusting levels, curves, sharpening and cropping? Are they considered different to cloning and substitutions? They are all Adobes programming.
Last edited on Thu Feb 15th, 2024 11:15 by
____________________
Eric