Moderated by: chrisbet,
Waterfall SwalletA secret, hidden gem  Rate Topic 
AuthorPost

Posted by Robert: Sat May 19th, 2018 03:23 1st Post
Waterfall Swallet is something I only discovered earlier this year in Derbyshire.

It's a sinkhole in limestone with a small river dropping over the edge, down a limestone cliff, then a few yards on, disappearing into clefts in the rock, quite a magical place. It's located near the small village of Foolow. In wet times the clefts can't dispose of the water fast enough, in which case it floods, maybe as much at 12 to 15 feet deep.

I have visited several times, most recently on my way to meet with Graham and Eric at Frampton RSPB. On this occasion I wanted to try to capture star trails through the tree canopy. The challenge was to also get a half decent image of the waterfall too, in the middle of the night.

Fortunately it was a moonless night, one less complication. I tried several ways to illuminate the waterfall and rock face, with a torch and by using my SB800 flash, hand held, making multiple flashes at 1:128 power during 30 second exposures.

I used the D3 with the 16mm f/2.8 lens. I made about ten exposures of the waterfall then locked the camera down and set the intervalometer to make 30 second exposures at 45 second intervals, started the intervalometer and retired to the car for about half an hour. This was about 2am. I wanted to get moving because I wasn't sure how long it would take me to get down to Frampton marsh.



I have to say the star trail exposures are far from perfect, the sky should have been blue, not grainy grey. Also, I should have made the image upright, that would have included the bottom of the waterfall and more sky, bu these things only become apparent after the event, will try harder next time.

The image is a collage, the lower half a single exposure, the upper half, sky made from about 25 exposures which were processed in StarstaX star processing software which creates the star trails. Some cloning and erasing done in Photoshop, returning to Lightroom then using NIK filters to extract more detail and an effect which seemed to get the most from the image, despite leaving it somewhat grainy.

So, my somewhat clumsy attempt to make a waterfall and star trail combination photograph.



____________________
Robert.


Posted by Eric: Sat May 19th, 2018 11:41 2nd Post
Robert wrote:
Waterfall Swallet is something I only discovered earlier this year in Derbyshire.

It's a sinkhole in limestone with a small river dropping over the edge, down a limestone cliff, then a few yards on, disappearing into clefts in the rock, quite a magical place. It's located near the small village of Foolow. In wet times the clefts can't dispose of the water fast enough, in which case it floods, maybe as much at 12 to 15 feet deep.

I have visited several times, most recently on my way to meet with Graham and Eric at Frampton RSPB. On this occasion I wanted to try to capture star trails through the tree canopy. The challenge was to also get a half decent image of the waterfall too, in the middle of the night.

Fortunately it was a moonless night, one less complication. I tried several ways to illuminate the waterfall and rock face, with a torch and by using my SB800 flash, hand held, making multiple flashes at 1:128 power during 30 second exposures.

I used the D3 with the 16mm f/2.8 lens. I made about ten exposures of the waterfall then locked the camera down and set the intervalometer to make 30 second exposures at 45 second intervals, started the intervalometer and retired to the car for about half an hour. This was about 2am. I wanted to get moving because I wasn't sure how long it would take me to get down to Frampton marsh.



I have to say the star trail exposures are far from perfect, the sky should have been blue, not grainy grey. Also, I should have made the image upright, that would have included the bottom of the waterfall and more sky, bu these things only become apparent after the event, will try harder next time.

The image is a collage, the lower half a single exposure, the upper half, sky made from about 25 exposures which were processed in StarstaX star processing software which creates the star trails. Some cloning and erasing done in Photoshop, returning to Lightroom then using NIK filters to extract more detail and an effect which seemed to get the most from the image, despite leaving it somewhat grainy.

So, my somewhat clumsy attempt to make a waterfall and star trail combination photograph.
Looks a very nice place! And super job.
A minor point...I would have liked the star trails a bit more prevalent.

Have you tried playing with layer modes?

You might be able to get the star trails more evident by using darker, lighter, overlay to name but a few. Presumably you put the star trails under the waterfall layer? Try a third layer with the stars on top and another mode. Multiply is another good one to increase contrast. Of course you can back off the opacity and do other stuff to minimise interference with foliage.

Just a thought.

Very nice work so far. :thumbs:

Sorry just reread your explanation re the collage. As you haven't got stars on separate layer from THIS shoot....why can't you use a plain sky shot of trails from another occasion as the third layer?



____________________
Eric


Posted by Robert: Sun May 20th, 2018 04:05 3rd Post
Eric wrote:
Looks a very nice place! And super job.
A minor point...I would have liked the star trails a bit more prevalent.

Have you tried playing with layer modes?

You might be able to get the star trails more evident by using darker, lighter, overlay to name but a few. Presumably you put the star trails under the waterfall layer? Try a third layer with the stars on top and another mode. Multiply is another good one to increase contrast. Of course you can back off the opacity and do other stuff to minimise interference with foliage.

Just a thought.

Very nice work so far. :thumbs:

Sorry just reread your explanation re the collage. As you haven't got stars on separate layer from THIS shoot....why can't you use a plain sky shot of trails from another occasion as the third layer?
I probably didn't describe clearly. I took about 25 exposures of the sky but they weren't well exposed. Hence the grey. I usually make several test exposures of the sky to get the right exposure by varying the ISO mainly and the aperture a little, sometimes reducing the shutter speed to 25 seconds. I was really testing the concept of trying to combine a light-painted rock face and the star trails. Usually I would have expected a very dark blue sky and a range of colours from ruby through white to sapphire in the stars. The sky was just grainy grey with completely blown white stars, suggesting over exposure? No amount of experimentation with the layers improved anything except perhaps contrast.

Also the boundary between the top of the rock face and the sky was just a black band, which was difficult to do anything with. It might be that it would be better to make the exposures of the rock and waterfall in the twilight, just before dark, rather than rely on flash alone, although I did use flash in daylight with good effect, because even in daylight it's pretty dark down there. Perhaps even bracket several exposures as darkness descends.

I have also considered using a small lamp lit continuously near the camera, even my head torch which I used to egress the scene then on my return to the camera on dim red, provided some illumination which had it been steady and constant would have improved the entire picture, shadows are another issue, I had to remove some harsh shadows from the flash.

I will re-visit on a good night, spend much more time and apply what I learnt that night, hopefully get something much better. It's a special place, a bit rugged but massive potential.

I probably could layer in another sky, after all it's exactly the same, just a different day! If a future attempt fails I might just do that, in a way this was just a reccey to find out what might work. I didn't want to spend too long because I wanted to get to Frampton with time for forty winks before you arrived, else I would have been even dopier than I was!



____________________
Robert.


Posted by Graham Whistler: Fri May 25th, 2018 18:30 4th Post
1st Class well done very dramatic pix!



____________________
Graham Whistler

Reply
1st new
This is topic ID = 1536  
Nikon DSLR Forums > Photography > Photography Expeditions & Travel > Waterfall Swallet Top

Users viewing this topic

Post quick reply

Current theme is Blue



A small amount of member data is captured and held in an attempt to reduce spammers and to manage users. This site also uses cookies to ensure ease of use. In order to comply with new DPR regulations you are required to agree/disagree with this process. If you do not agree then please email the Admins using info@nikondsl.uk Thank you.


Hosted by Octarine Services

UltraBB 1.173 Copyright © 2008-2024 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.0241 seconds (64% database + 36% PHP). 53 queries executed.